And time for another edition of Movie Reviews for people with kids, wherein I review movies that are six months to a year old, not because I’m lazy, but because being a parent with small children it is easier to get a turnip and a wombat to mate successfully than it is for my wife and I to get a night out.
Interestingly enough, having a wombat wake up in bed with a turnip is the plot of Hangover Part 3: the Wombatening.
It’s not. I just like saying wombat. Wombat. Heh.
This week, I take on Charlize Theron, Thor, and a block of wood in the cinematic, uh… experience: Snow White and the Huntsman.
Kristin Stewart shown here conveying the incomprehensible human emotion “Happy”
Let Mortal Wombat begin!
Ready…. Fight!
Alright, so it’s a movie based loosely on the fairy tale. Charlize Theron plays the evil queen, who pretends to a be a prisoner of an evil magic army, so that the Snow White’s father, the king, will fall in love with her and marry her, so she can kill him in their bed chamber, open the castle gates to her real human army, and steal the kingdom for herself and her creepy brother with whom there is an implied incestuous inclination.
All well and good so far, but then the Queen opts to keep the child whose father she murdered and whose throne she just usurped alive, imprisoned in a tower in her castle. She has no reason to keep her alive at this point. She doesn’t know that Snow White is the key to her immortality, she just spares her life, but locks her away forever presumably.
Queen Charlize has not read the evil overlord list.
My noble half-brother (or in this case, step-daughter) whose throne I usurped will be killed, not kept anonymously imprisoned in a forgotten cell of my dungeon.
In fact, it’s useful to have the list open while watching this movie, because you’ll be able to spot all sorts of problems with Queen Charlize acting like a clichéd evil overlord and not like a woman who just executed a smart, ruthless plan to seize power.
Here’s a list of her shortcomings that I came up with:
I will not order my trusted lieutenant to kill the infant who is destined to overthrow me — I’ll do it myself.
Later in the movie, when Snow White has grown up, the evil Queen discovers that if she just eats Snow White’s heart, she’ll be immortal and powerful forever. The evil Queen dispatches one guy to her prison cell without backup or guards guarding the door to the tower and Snow White promptly escapes and locks her idiot brother into her cell.
- I will hire a team of board-certified architects and surveyors to examine my castle and inform me of any secret passages and abandoned tunnels that I might not know about.
- My ventilation ducts will be too small to crawl through.
Snow White’s method for escaping the castle is to slide into the sewers through an open hole that is big enough for a man to crawl through. Amazingly enough, the Queen doesn’t order her minions to block the entrance with a grate or iron bars or something that would let sewage through but prevent people from using the sewer tunnel as an access point to her otherwise secure castle. Suffice to say, this decision comes back to bite her in the butt later.
I will only employ bounty hunters who work for money.
When Snow White escapes into the Dark Forest, the Queen’s brother (the aforementioned idiot) suggests getting Thor the Huntsman to go and get her. Thor refuses to do it at any price until the Queen intimates that she can resurrect his dead wife which she can’t do, so, I’m not sure what they thought would happen when he found out, but predictably, he helps her escape.
I will not gloat over my enemies’ predicament before killing them.
Seriously, villains… this never ends well. Stop it.
I will be neither chivalrous nor sporting. If I have an unstoppable superweapon, I will use it as early and as often as possible instead of keeping it in reserve.
Late in the movie, when Snow White has raised and army and stormed her castle and killed her soldiers, the Queen unleashes a flying, shapeshifting, metallic, magical swarm creature that cannot be killed and is wiping the floor with Snow’s troops. The question of why she didn’t just unleash this thing when they were all outside of her castle or why she never used this thing to go breach the castle of her enemy the Duke is never answered.
But having a villain who falls prey to stupid behavior isn’t the only problem of the movie or even the biggest problem of the movie. That falls to Snow White… our aforementioned block of wood.
I’m happy!
Okay, Snow White is what is generally referred to in fiction as a Mary Sue. She is a character whose positive traits are told, not shown to us. She is innately special because… she is. She makes everyone fall in love with her without doing anything, pledge themselves in loyalty and sacrifice their lives and happiness for her because she’s so darn special. But she never actually shows us that. She mostly walks around looking a bit stoned, so that when she finally has a bite of the poison apple, you’re hard pressed to tell that she’s unconscious. If you strapped her to a dolly and kept her upright, you couldn’t tell the difference.
Kristin Stewart shown here conveying the human emotion: Sad.
Chris Hemsworth does a serviceable job as the Huntsman, but really, the story lives and dies by the Queen and Snow White and overall, I was a bit let down.
Given the two movies based on Snow White that I’ve seen this year, Mirror Mirror is definitely the better one.
Snow White and the Huntsman is good for a $1 rental, but not much more.